Current Issue
Vol. 4 No. 3 (2026), published 7 September 2026.
Read Current Issue
Vol. 4 No. 3 (2026)
Published: 7 September 2026. The current issue and its article-level metadata are maintained by the AAAR OJS issue page. Article titles, authors, pages, and DOI records should be consulted there rather than copied from an unverified extract.
Aims & Scope
AAAR welcomes rigorous research and literature reviews contributing meaningfully to applied accounting knowledge, reporting, governance, sustainability, digital accounting, and related recognized fields.
Read Full Aims & Scope
Aims & Scope
Advances in Applied Accounting Research (AAAR) is an international, peer-reviewed, open-access scholarly journal dedicated to advancing theoretically grounded, methodologically rigorous, and practically relevant research addressing accounting-related problems in organizations and wider society. The journal provides an international scholarly platform for research that contributes to understanding accounting theories, practices, institutions, governance, financial reporting, managerial decision-making, sustainability, technological transformation, and related accounting phenomena.
AAAR recognizes that organizations and societies operate in environments characterized by rapid change, complexity, volatility, uncertainty, and ambiguity. The journal seeks to advance scholarly understanding of accounting-related developments and challenges while encouraging research that anticipates, examines, and responds to transformations in contemporary accounting environments.
The journal emphasizes that applied accounting research complements theoretical inquiry. AAAR encourages scholars in accounting, finance, governance, economics, management, organization studies, and law to contribute research that develops, tests, extends, integrates, or critically evaluates accounting-related knowledge. Research should demonstrate how theoretical understanding and evidence from professional practice can inform one another and generate meaningful scholarly and practical contributions.
Accounting-Centered Scope Principle: All scholarly areas identified below constitute recognized components of AAAR's accounting-related scope. Each area may independently establish manuscript relevance when the research demonstrates a substantive connection to accounting knowledge, practices, institutions, reporting, governance, financial decision-making, or accounting-related societal issues. Interdisciplinary contributions are welcome when their principal scholarly questions and findings remain meaningfully connected to accounting research.
AAAR welcomes contextualized applied accounting research with clear theoretical foundations, defensible methodologies, meaningful scholarly contributions, and carefully developed practical implications. The journal encourages research that connects academic knowledge with professional practice, advances field-driven theoretical understanding, and contributes to addressing contemporary challenges affecting organizations, financial institutions, policymakers, and wider society.
Financial Accounting, Reporting & Accounting Standards
Financial Accounting and Reporting includes financial accounting principles, accounting recognition and measurement, financial statements, financial disclosure, financial reporting quality, accounting information, reporting practices, financial transparency, accounting judgment, and the relevance of financial information to organizational and stakeholder decision-making.
International Accounting Standards and Standard Setting includes international financial reporting standards, accounting standard setting, accounting regulation, financial reporting frameworks, accounting policy choices, financial reporting comparability, accounting harmonization, and the adoption, interpretation, implementation, and practical implications of accounting standards.
Accounting Information and Financial Accountability includes the preparation, communication, interpretation, and use of accounting information, organizational financial accountability, financial reporting practices, reporting transparency, and the relationship between accounting information and financial or institutional decision-making.
Management Accounting, Corporate Finance & Shareholder Value
Management Accounting includes managerial accounting practices, cost accounting, budgeting, financial planning, management control, performance measurement, management reporting, organizational resource allocation, managerial decision-making, and the application of accounting information to organizational planning and performance evaluation.
Corporate Financial Management includes financial management practices, corporate financing decisions, investment decisions, capital structure, working capital management, financial planning, financial risk, financial performance, financial strategy, and accounting-related considerations in corporate financial decision-making.
Business and Shareholder Value includes business valuation, firm value, shareholder value, financial performance, corporate accountability, financial decision-making, and the relationships among accounting information, organizational performance, corporate financial management, and stakeholder interests.
Corporate Governance, Internal Control & Accountability
Good Governance and Internal Control Structures includes corporate governance, organizational governance, governance mechanisms, internal control systems, financial oversight, accountability structures, risk management, governance transparency, and the relationships between governance arrangements and accounting or financial reporting outcomes.
Accounting and Organizational Governance includes the role of accounting information in organizational oversight, financial accountability, governance decision-making, management responsibility, stakeholder accountability, institutional control, and the development and evaluation of effective governance practices.
Governance, Financial Reporting and Stakeholder Interests includes the relationships among reporting practices, financial transparency, governance quality, shareholder interests, organizational responsibilities, and the application of accounting knowledge to strengthen institutional and corporate accountability.
Public-Sector Accounting, Organizations & Institutions
Public-Sector Accounting includes governmental accounting, public financial management, public-sector financial reporting, accountability in public institutions, public resource management, financial transparency, public-sector performance measurement, and accounting practices in governmental and nonprofit organizations.
Accounting and Organisations includes accounting practices within organizations, organizational accounting systems, accounting and institutional arrangements, the use of accounting information in organizational processes, management control, organizational accountability, and the relationship between accounting practices and organizational behavior or decision-making.
Institutional and Organizational Accounting Contexts includes accounting-related practices, challenges, and transformations within private, public, nonprofit, and other institutional settings. Research may examine how organizational and institutional contexts influence accounting practices, financial information, accountability, and decision-making.
Professional Accounting Practice & Academic Engagement
Professional Accounting Practice and the Academic Nexus includes professional accounting practices, accounting knowledge in professional settings, relationships between academic research and accounting practice, professional decision-making, accounting competencies, and the translation of accounting theories and research findings into practical applications.
Industry-Academia Collaboration includes rigorous scholarly research arising from engagement between academic researchers, accounting practitioners, financial institutions, organizations, and professional communities. AAAR particularly welcomes research that examines practical accounting problems while developing meaningful theoretical, methodological, or policy-relevant insights.
Applied Accounting Knowledge and Professional Relevance includes research that connects accounting concepts, analytical approaches, professional experiences, and institutional practices to improve understanding of accounting-related organizational and societal challenges.
Societal Accounting, Equality & Social Innovation
Societal Aspects of Accounting includes the relationships between accounting practices and society, the social implications of financial information, public accountability, accounting-related institutional responsibilities, stakeholder interests, and the contribution of accounting knowledge to understanding wider societal problems.
Equality, Diversity and Accounting includes equality, diversity, inclusion, fairness, and related societal considerations in accounting practices, professional accounting environments, financial reporting, governance, organizational accountability, and accounting-related decision-making.
Social Innovation and Emerging Economies includes accounting-related dimensions of social innovation, institutional development, emerging economies, social and financial inclusion, responsible organizational practices, and the role of accounting knowledge in addressing economic and societal challenges.
Sustainability, ESG Accounting & Green Finance
Sustainability and ESG Accounting includes sustainability accounting, environmental accounting, social accounting, sustainability reporting, environmental, social and governance (ESG) disclosure, sustainability performance measurement, corporate responsibility, accounting-related sustainability governance, and the application of accounting information to sustainability-related organizational decisions.
Impact Investing and Accounting for Green Finance includes impact investing, sustainable investment, green finance, climate-related finance, financial accountability for sustainability initiatives, sustainability-related financial information, and the measurement, reporting, and evaluation of financial and non-financial outcomes associated with responsible investment.
Sustainability Accounting and Global Challenges includes accounting-related approaches to environmental and societal challenges, sustainable organizational practices, responsible financial decision-making, sustainability disclosure, and the contribution of accounting research to the Sustainable Development Goals and wider sustainable development priorities.
Digital Accounting, Information Systems & Technological Transformation
Digital Accounting and Accounting Information Systems includes accounting information systems, digital accounting practices, accounting information technologies, technology-enabled financial reporting, digital financial information, accounting data management, and the application of information systems to accounting processes and organizational decision-making.
Technological Innovation in Accounting includes digital transformation of accounting practices, accounting automation, artificial intelligence in accounting, digital reporting, accounting analytics, emerging technologies, and technological developments that influence accounting information, professional accounting practices, reporting, governance, or financial accountability.
Digital Transformation and Organizational Accounting includes research examining how technological developments reshape accounting systems, financial information, accounting-related management processes, organizational control, professional practices, and the capacity of organizations to respond to changing accounting environments.
Futures, Financial Developments & Emerging Challenges
Futures and the Financial World includes accounting-related perspectives on developments in financial institutions, financial practices, financial decision-making, financial systems, and emerging challenges affecting the contemporary financial environment.
Accounting and Financial Change includes research examining accounting-related responses to financial uncertainty, organizational transformation, emerging financial practices, changing economic environments, and developments affecting the production, interpretation, and use of accounting and financial information.
Contemporary Accounting Challenges includes research addressing new and evolving accounting-related problems in a volatile, uncertain, complex, and ambiguous world. AAAR encourages theoretically grounded and evidence-based perspectives that contribute to understanding future accounting practices and their organizational or societal implications.
Methodological Innovation & Interdisciplinary Accounting Research
Methodological Innovations in Accounting Research includes the development, adaptation, evaluation, and application of quantitative, qualitative, mixed-method, conceptual, analytical, and other defensible scholarly approaches that advance understanding of accounting-related theories, evidence, practices, institutions, or problems.
Interdisciplinary, Multidisciplinary and Transdisciplinary Research includes research connecting accounting with finance, governance, economics, management, organization studies, law, and related fields. Contributions should establish a clear and substantive relationship with accounting research rather than relying on a merely incidental accounting context.
Theoretical and Applied Research Integration includes studies that examine accounting-related phenomena through theoretical development, empirical investigation, methodological innovation, critical scholarly evaluation, and practical application. AAAR welcomes research that strengthens connections between conceptual understanding, evidence, and accounting practice.
Accepted Manuscript Types
AAAR accepts manuscripts written in English under only two recognized manuscript types: Research Paper and Literature Review Paper.
Research Paper includes original empirical research using quantitative, qualitative, mixed-method, experimental, quasi-experimental, archival, longitudinal, cross-sectional, comparative, case-based, content-analytical, textual, behavioral, computational, accounting-analytical, or other defensible original-research designs. Research should establish an accounting-related scholarly problem and present evidence, analysis, findings, and conclusions consistent with the research procedures actually undertaken.
Literature Review Paper includes rigorous narrative, integrative, systematic, scoping, structured, bibliometric, meta-analytical, theory-oriented, concept-oriented, or other defensible literature-review designs. Reviews should employ transparent methods appropriate to the review design and provide meaningful scholarly synthesis, theoretical or conceptual insights, critical evaluation, methodological understanding, or clearly grounded future-research directions relevant to accounting research.
Manuscript-Type Principle: Research methodologies, analytical techniques, theoretical or conceptual contributions, and literature-review approaches do not constitute separate manuscript types. Conceptual Papers are not accepted as a separate manuscript category. Conceptual and theoretical contributions should be appropriately integrated into an eligible manuscript type and supported by a defensible research or review approach. Bibliometric and mapping-based reviews should provide substantive scholarly synthesis rather than descriptive mapping alone.
Methodological Integrity: Authors must accurately describe the research or literature-review design actually undertaken. Specialized methodological claims must be supported by the procedures genuinely conducted and the evidence available. All manuscripts must demonstrate scientific rigor, coherent scholarly argumentation, clear academic English, and compliance with AAAR's current manuscript requirements. The journal's original editorial criteria specify a manuscript length of around 7,000 words; authors should follow the applicable current submission guidelines.
Scholarly Contributions & Research Relevance
AAAR welcomes scholarly work that generates meaningful empirical, theoretical, conceptual, methodological, professional, practical, institutional, policy-related, or literature-synthesis contributions within its recognized accounting-related scope. The journal particularly encourages research that demonstrates how academic knowledge and professional accounting practice can inform and strengthen one another.
Empirical, Theoretical and Conceptual Contributions include generating, testing, replicating, extending, integrating, refining, challenging, or critically evaluating accounting-related evidence, theories, concepts, relationships, research models, analytical frameworks, and professional or institutional practices.
Methodological and Literature-Synthesis Contributions include developing, adapting, applying, evaluating, or critically examining accounting research methodologies and systematically or critically synthesizing relevant scholarly literature to identify evidence patterns, theoretical debates, methodological challenges, knowledge gaps, and future research opportunities.
Professional, Practical, Policy and Societal Contributions include evidence-based implications for accounting professionals, organizations, managers, financial institutions, investors, regulators, policymakers, public institutions, professional communities, and wider society. Practical implications should be carefully derived from the research findings or scholarly synthesis and supported by appropriate theoretical reflection.
International, Institutional & Practical Relevance
AAAR welcomes research investigating accounting-related phenomena in private, public, governmental, nonprofit, financial, professional, educational, institutional, and other relevant organizational settings. Research may examine accounting practices, financial reporting, governance, managerial accounting, professional activities, sustainability, technological developments, or accounting-related societal challenges.
Single-country, multi-country, local, regional, national, international, single-industry, single-company, and single-organization studies may be eligible when they establish a meaningful accounting-related scholarly problem and provide defensible theoretical, empirical, methodological, practical, professional, institutional, or policy-relevant insights.
International or multi-country data are not mandatory. Contextually grounded applied accounting research should explain how its findings, analytical interpretations, or literature synthesis contribute to broader scholarly understanding and relevant accounting practice rather than presenting exclusively descriptive organizational or operational information.
Key Journal Audiences: AAAR serves accounting scholars and researchers interested in practically relevant and theoretically grounded accounting research; academics and interdisciplinary scholars investigating accounting-related problems; professionals in accounting, finance, and financial services; organizational and institutional decision-makers; regulators and policymakers; and readers interested in accounting-informed approaches to organizational and societal challenges.
Scope Compliance & Editorial Screening
Manuscripts should clearly identify an accounting-related research or review problem, the relevant scholarly context, theoretical or conceptual foundation, research objectives, methodology or review methodology, evidence, analysis or synthesis, findings, interpretation, implications, and substantive contribution to accounting knowledge or practice. Relevance may be established through any recognized area of AAAR's accounting-centered scholarly scope.
Editorial Criteria: AAAR welcomes rigorous and well-structured scholarly research employing appropriate quantitative, qualitative, mixed-method, interdisciplinary, multidisciplinary, or transdisciplinary approaches. Manuscripts should demonstrate clear academic argumentation, methodological defensibility, appropriate contextualization, coherent scholarly presentation, sound English-language communication, and carefully derived theoretical and practical implications.
Out-of-Scope Research includes studies whose principal questions, theoretical foundations, analytical focus, and scholarly contributions do not relate substantively to accounting or the recognized accounting-related areas of AAAR. Research situated in economics, finance, management, law, technology, organizational studies, or other disciplines should demonstrate a meaningful accounting-related contribution rather than relying on an incidental or nominal connection to accounting.
Descriptive reports, consultancy-style accounts, and local operational descriptions that do not establish a scholarly problem, defensible analytical or review framework, and meaningful contribution to knowledge may also be considered unsuitable for publication. Contemporary or practically important subject matter alone does not replace the need for scientific rigor, theoretical reflection, appropriate evidence, and scholarly contribution.
Editorial Screening: Manuscripts that clearly fall outside AAAR's Aims & Scope, do not conform to one of the two recognized manuscript types, lack adequate scholarly contribution, or fail essential manuscript preparation, submission, or research-integrity requirements may be declined during initial editorial screening without external peer review.
Publication Eligibility: Alignment with the journal's scope does not guarantee acceptance or publication. Every manuscript remains subject to originality, research integrity, appropriate methodology or review methodology, scholarly quality, submission compliance, independent peer review, editorial evaluation, and applicable publication-ethics policies. Editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit and must remain independent of publication payments.
Current Scope Framework
The current AAAR Aims & Scope framework is intended to guide the scholarly assessment of new manuscripts within the journal's recognized accounting-related fields. All areas identified in this framework form part of the journal's accounting-centered scholarly scope, with manuscript relevance assessed according to the substantive accounting-related contribution of the research.
Valid manuscripts, editorial decisions, previously published articles, volume and issue assignments, publication dates, bibliographic metadata, DOI records, and other historical scholarly records established under earlier journal policies remain part of AAAR's permanent scholarly record and are not retrospectively reclassified, removed, or altered merely to conform to the current framework.
Authors, editors, and reviewers should apply the current framework to new submissions while respecting valid editorial commitments, decisions, and publication records associated with earlier manuscripts. The implementation of updated editorial or scope requirements does not invalidate legitimate historical publication records.
Prospective authors should consult the current manuscript requirements, manuscript template, applicable submission guidelines, peer-review requirements, publication ethics, Article Processing Charge policy, and other relevant journal information before submitting their work.
For Authors
AAAR accepts Research Papers and Literature Review Papers in English. Authors must submit a Blinded Manuscript and separate Title Page through the official OJS workflow.
Read Full Author Guidelines
For Authors
Authors intending to submit to Advances in Applied Accounting Research (AAAR) should review the current Aims & Scope, accepted manuscript types, manuscript requirements, official manuscript template, separate Title Page requirements, peer-review process, publication ethics, Article Processing Charge policy, Open Access and licensing terms, and other applicable journal policies before submission.
AAAR accepts manuscripts written in English only. Authors should prepare original, academically rigorous, clearly written, and ethically compliant manuscripts that make a substantive scholarly contribution to accounting research or a recognized accounting-related field included in the journal's current Aims & Scope.
All formal submissions must be made through the official AAAR Online Journal System (OJS). Manuscripts submitted only through personal email, messaging applications, or unofficial communication channels do not constitute formal journal submissions.
Scope & Accepted Manuscript Types
AAAR welcomes theoretically grounded, methodologically rigorous, and practically relevant research addressing accounting-related problems in organizations and wider society. Its recognized scholarly areas include financial accounting and reporting, accounting standards, management accounting, corporate financial management, business and shareholder value, corporate governance, internal control, public-sector accounting, accounting and organizations, professional accounting practice, societal accounting, equality and diversity in accounting, sustainability and ESG accounting, impact investing, green finance, digital accounting, accounting information systems, methodological innovation, and accounting-related interdisciplinary research.
Accounting-Centered Scope Principle: A manuscript may establish scope eligibility through a substantive contribution to any recognized accounting-related area within the current AAAR Aims & Scope. Interdisciplinary studies involving finance, governance, economics, management, organization studies, law, technology, or related fields are welcome when their research questions, theoretical foundations, analysis, findings, or scholarly contributions demonstrate a meaningful connection to accounting research.
AAAR accepts two manuscript types only: Research Paper and Literature Review Paper.
Research Paper presents original research using quantitative, qualitative, mixed-method, experimental, quasi-experimental, longitudinal, panel-data, cross-sectional, comparative, econometric, archival, computational, case-based, behavioral, textual, accounting-analytical, or other defensible original-research designs. The study must demonstrate appropriate theoretical or conceptual grounding, transparent methods, credible findings, and a substantive accounting-related scholarly contribution.
Literature Review Paper presents a rigorous scholarly synthesis using an accurately identified and sufficiently transparent narrative, integrative, systematic, scoping, structured, bibliometric, meta-analytical, theory-oriented, concept-oriented, or other defensible literature-review approach. The manuscript must provide meaningful critical synthesis, theoretical or conceptual insights, methodological understanding, scholarly interpretation, or a focused future-research agenda relevant to accounting research.
Manuscript-Type Principle: Research designs, analytical techniques, datasets, conceptual contributions, methodological approaches, and literature-review techniques do not constitute separate manuscript types. Conceptual Papers are not accepted as a separate category. Theoretical, conceptual, empirical, professional, practical, policy, and methodological contributions may be developed within an eligible Research Paper or Literature Review Paper.
Required Submission Files
Authors must prepare and submit two separate files: (1) a Blinded Manuscript and (2) a Title Page & Author Information Form. These files serve different editorial purposes and must not be combined into a single submission document.
1. Blinded Manuscript: The blinded manuscript contains the article title, structured abstract, keywords, selected manuscript type, main text, tables, figures, supporting material where applicable, and references. It must not contain author names, institutional affiliations, author email addresses, acknowledgements revealing identity, identifying document properties, or other information that could reasonably disclose author identity.
2. Title Page & Author Information Form: The separate Title Page contains verified author names, institutional affiliations, email addresses, corresponding-author details, ORCID information, CRediT contributions, funding, conflicts of interest, Data Availability Statement, acknowledgements, research ethics and consent information where applicable, Generative AI disclosure, third-party permissions, and applicable author and publication declarations.
The corresponding author's ORCID is required. Other authors should provide their ORCID where available. Authors must verify that the institutional and corresponding-author information entered in OJS is consistent with the separate Title Page.
Before submission, authors must confirm that the manuscript is original, is not simultaneously under consideration by another journal, follows the selected AAAR manuscript type, complies with the current Aims & Scope, and satisfies the journal's research-integrity and submission requirements.
Manuscript Template & General Format
Manuscripts should be prepared using the current official Advances in Research Master Manuscript Template. The main text must be written in clear academic English using Calisto MT, 11 pt, A4 page size, a single-column layout, and single spacing. Unnecessary blank space, inconsistent formatting, excessive repetition, and unused template instructions should be removed before submission.
The manuscript title must contain no more than 20 words. The structured abstract must not exceed 200 words. Authors must provide 1–6 relevant keywords and select only one of the two accepted manuscript types. The main text must follow the structure appropriate to the selected type.
AAAR's original editorial criteria specify a manuscript length of around 7,000 words. Authors should follow the applicable current manuscript requirements and official template when preparing their submissions.
The current manuscript template contains separate instructions for Research Papers and Literature Review Papers. Authors must retain only the appropriate manuscript structure and remove instructions or sections that do not apply to their selected paper type. Procedures, analytical techniques, software, statistical tests, review protocols, and other methodological details must be reported only when genuinely used.
The official manuscript template and Title Page must be obtained from the designated master-template links below. Authors should use the current versions and ensure consistency between their files and the metadata supplied through OJS.
Structured Abstract
The abstract must be written in English, follow the labels corresponding to the selected manuscript type, and contain no more than 200 words. It should present the scholarly objective, research or review methodology, principal substantive findings, implications, and originality without unnecessarily reproducing the detailed numerical output presented in the manuscript.
Research Paper: Use the structured labels Purpose; Research Methodology; Results; Research limitations/Implications; Originality. The abstract should state the research objective or question, summarize the actual research design and analytical approach, communicate the principal empirical findings, identify material limitations and implications, and explain the study's novelty or scholarly contribution.
Literature Review Paper: Use the structured labels Purpose; Review Methodology; Findings; Research limitations/Implications; Originality. The abstract should state the review objective or question, describe the actual review approach, summarize the principal patterns, themes, debates, gaps, or conceptual insights, identify limitations and implications, and explain the review's distinctive scholarly contribution.
Detailed coefficients, p-values, test statistics, confidence intervals, fit indices, bibliometric counts, and other numerical outputs should normally be presented in the main text rather than the abstract. A specific numerical value should be included in the abstract only when essential to understanding the principal substantive finding. Authors must not exaggerate the strength, significance, generalizability, or implications of their findings.
Research Paper Structure
A Research Paper should follow the current official manuscript template and normally use the main structure Introduction → Review of Literature → Research Methodology → Results and Discussion → Conclusion. Within Results and Discussion, empirical results and their scholarly interpretation must remain clearly distinguishable.
1. Introduction: Establish the state of the art, scholarly context, research problem, literature gap, novelty, objectives or research questions, and theoretical, methodological, professional, practical, or policy significance. Clearly explain why the accounting-related study matters and what contribution it intends to make.
2. Review of Literature: Critically evaluate and synthesize relevant theories, concepts, and prior empirical evidence. Explain consistencies, disagreements, unresolved questions, and relevant research gaps. Develop an appropriate conceptual foundation, research model, propositions, or hypotheses where justified. The section should advance an argument rather than merely list previous studies.
3. Research Methodology: Report the procedures genuinely used to generate and analyze the evidence. Describe the research design, population or unit of analysis, sample or case selection, research context, data sources, collection procedures, variables or constructs, measurement, analytical techniques, model specifications, validity or reliability procedures, software, and ethical safeguards where applicable. This section must describe methods rather than present empirical findings.
4. Results and Discussion: This main section should distinguish the presentation of evidence from scholarly interpretation, using the appropriate subheadings of the current template.
4.1 Research Results: Present the empirical findings accurately and transparently using relevant descriptive, statistical, qualitative, model-based, experimental, comparative, or other research evidence. Include material findings that do not support proposed hypotheses. Report appropriate tables, figures, analytical outputs, and substantive results without unnecessarily repeating every numerical value in the narrative.
4.2 Discussion: Interpret the substantive meaning of the results in relation to the theoretical or conceptual framework, previous accounting-related research, the study context, and relevant scholarly debates. Explain agreements, differences, unexpected findings, and theoretical, methodological, organizational, governance, financial, professional, practical, societal, or policy implications as applicable. Avoid repeating detailed coefficients, p-values, test statistics, tables, and findings already reported in the Research Results subsection.
5. Conclusion: Provide a concise synthesis that directly answers the research objectives, identifies the principal contribution, explains the most important implications, acknowledges relevant limitations, and proposes focused, defensible future-research directions. The Conclusion must not simply reproduce the Abstract, Results, or Discussion.
Evidence Placement Principle: Research Methodology explains what was done; Research Results reports what the evidence shows; Discussion interprets what the findings mean; and Conclusion states what the study ultimately establishes. Each section must perform a distinct scholarly function and avoid unnecessary duplication.
Literature Review Paper Structure
A Literature Review Paper should normally follow the structure Introduction → Review Methodology → Review Findings / Literature Synthesis → Discussion → Conclusion. Review methodology, evidence synthesis, interpretation, and conclusions must be presented as distinct scholarly functions.
1. Introduction: Establish the accounting-related scholarly problem, review context, state of the literature, knowledge gap, review question or objective, significance, and intended contribution. Explain why a literature review is needed and what the review seeks to clarify, synthesize, extend, or critically evaluate.
2. Review Methodology: Accurately identify the review design and describe how the literature was identified, selected, organized, evaluated, and synthesized. Information sources, databases, search strategies, eligibility criteria, screening procedures, duplicate handling, analytical approaches, and software should be reported where applicable to the review actually conducted. Not all procedures are required for every review design.
3. Review Findings / Literature Synthesis: Present a substantive synthesis of the evidence through meaningful themes, concepts, theoretical perspectives, research streams, scholarly debates, methodological patterns, chronological developments, or research gaps. Quantitative and bibliometric findings should be reported here when relevant. Avoid a purely descriptive study-by-study listing without meaningful synthesis.
4. Discussion: Interpret the synthesis at a higher scholarly level. Explain what the accumulated literature establishes, where disagreements or limitations remain, how the review extends or challenges existing accounting-related knowledge, and what theoretical, conceptual, methodological, professional, governance, financial, practical, societal, or policy implications follow. Avoid repeating detailed bibliometric counts, tables, and evidence already presented.
5. Conclusion: Answer the review objective, synthesize its principal insights, explain originality and contribution, identify limitations, and provide a focused future-research agenda. Conclusions must remain proportionate to the evidence reviewed and should not merely restate the findings or discussion.
Review Integrity: Authors must accurately describe the review design actually conducted. Manuscripts must not claim systematic, PRISMA-based, scoping, bibliometric, meta-analytical, database-search, screening, or other specialized procedures unless those procedures were genuinely performed. A PRISMA flow diagram is appropriate only when the review design and actual procedures support its use. Bibliometric mapping or descriptive classification alone is insufficient where substantive scholarly synthesis is absent.
Tables, Figures & Language Quality
Tables and figures should be relevant, accurate, clearly numbered, appropriately titled, and placed near their first substantive discussion in the manuscript. Tables and figures must be numbered separately and consecutively. Table titles and figure titles should appear above the respective items, while sources, notes, and explanatory information should appear below.
Figures, diagrams, conceptual frameworks, thematic maps, review-flow diagrams, statistical charts, and bibliometric visualizations must accurately reflect the research design, review methodology, underlying evidence, and findings. Raster figures should preferably have a resolution of at least 300 DPI where applicable. All labels, symbols, data, arrows, relationships, and visual elements must remain clear and publication-ready.
Authors are responsible for securing and documenting necessary copyright permissions for reproduced or adapted figures, tables, datasets, images, and other third-party materials. Unattributed reproduction, materially misleading visual modification, or alteration of research evidence is not acceptable.
AAAR accepts submissions in English only. Manuscripts must demonstrate appropriate grammar, academic tone, clarity, readability, terminology consistency, logical paragraph development, coherence, inclusive language, and international scholarly readability. Authors should follow relevant APA guidance concerning bias-free language.
Language editing and proofreading must preserve the scientific meaning, analytical evidence, research findings, conceptual relationships, and authorial claims. Authors are not required to purchase a commercial language-editing service as a condition of scholarly consideration or acceptance.
References & Citation Integrity
All in-text citations and reference-list entries must follow APA Style, 7th edition. Manuscripts should include at least 25 references, with at least 80% of references drawn from journal articles. Authors should prioritize relevant and recent scholarship, generally from approximately the last ten years, while retaining important seminal or foundational studies where academically necessary.
Literature Review Papers must draw on a sufficiently broad, appropriate, and defensible body of literature for the review objective, design, and scholarly contribution. The minimum reference requirement does not replace the need for adequate literature coverage or rigorous synthesis.
Every work cited in the manuscript must appear in the reference list, and every reference-list entry must be cited in the manuscript. Authors must verify the accuracy of author names, publication years, titles, journal names, volume and issue details, page ranges, publishers, DOIs, URLs, and other bibliographic metadata. DOI links should be provided whenever available, and stable URLs should be supplied for eligible online sources.
References must be genuine, traceable, relevant, and accurately represented. Fabricated, fictitious, hallucinated, materially inaccurate, misleading, or unverifiable references are not permitted. Sources must not be cited as supporting claims that they do not substantiate.
Authors are strongly encouraged to use reference-management software such as Zotero, Mendeley, or EndNote and to complete a thorough citation-to-reference reconciliation before submission. The corresponding author and all coauthors retain responsibility for the accuracy and integrity of the submitted reference list.
Authorship, ORCID & Publication Declarations
All listed authors must have made appropriate scholarly contributions, approved the submitted manuscript, agreed to the reported authorship order, and accepted responsibility for the integrity of the work. Authorship must reflect genuine contribution rather than honorary, guest, gift, or otherwise unsupported authorship arrangements.
The corresponding author's ORCID is mandatory. Other authors should provide their ORCID where available. Authorship contributions must be reported using the current CRediT contributor-role framework, accurately reflecting each author's actual contributions.
The separate Title Page & Author Information Form must include the final article title, selected manuscript type, manuscript identification number where already assigned, full author names without academic titles or ranks, complete affiliations, email addresses, corresponding-author information, ORCID details, and applicable CRediT contributions.
Authors must accurately complete applicable declarations concerning research ethics, institutional or organizational approval, informed consent, publication consent, data-use permission, confidentiality, funding, conflicts of interest, Data Availability, acknowledgements, Generative AI or AI-assisted technologies, third-party material permissions, originality, concurrent submission, final manuscript approval, and author accountability.
Ethics approvals, approval numbers, consent statements, institutional authorizations, permissions, funding information, data-access claims, author contributions, and other publication declarations must not be invented, inferred, or presented inaccurately. Where a declaration does not apply, its status must be reported truthfully in accordance with the Title Page instructions and journal policy.
The official Title Page incorporates the normal author-confirmation process. A separate author statement letter is not required in the standard AAAR workflow unless specifically requested by the Editorial Office. The Title Page must remain separate from the blinded manuscript throughout the applicable anonymous review process.
Generative AI
Generative AI systems and AI-assisted tools cannot be listed as authors or credited with human authorship responsibility because they cannot assume accountability for originality, accuracy, research integrity, ethical compliance, or the final published scholarly record.
Authors remain fully responsible for the manuscript's content, research design, data, analysis, interpretation, citations, references, originality, confidentiality, ethical compliance, and final scholarly claims. AI-generated or AI-assisted text, calculations, citations, summaries, interpretations, code, figures, and other outputs must be independently checked and verified before inclusion.
Substantive use of Generative AI or AI-assisted technologies must be disclosed accurately where applicable, using the journal's designated Title Page or declaration process. Authors must not upload confidential data, identifiable participant information, unpublished third-party materials, or otherwise protected content into external systems where confidentiality, authorization, intellectual-property rights, and appropriate data protection cannot be assured.
Peer Review & Editorial Decision
AAAR applies double-anonymous peer review. The identities of authors are not disclosed to reviewers, and the identities of reviewers are not disclosed to authors. The separate Title Page is maintained outside the blinded manuscript for the purposes of confidential editorial administration and author verification.
Submitted manuscripts undergo initial editorial screening for Aims & Scope relevance, correct manuscript type, originality, scholarly contribution, methodological or review-methodological adequacy, research integrity, citation accuracy, anonymization, similarity concerns, and compliance with journal submission requirements.
Manuscripts that pass editorial screening are normally evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with appropriate substantive, theoretical, conceptual, or methodological expertise. Reviewers provide independent scholarly assessments and recommendations. Reviewer recommendations are advisory rather than automatically binding.
Authors may be requested to revise their manuscripts and provide clear, accurate responses to reviewer and editorial comments. Revised submissions are evaluated to determine whether substantive concerns have been adequately addressed and whether material scientific, ethical, methodological, or integrity problems remain.
Final scientific-editorial responsibility remains with the responsible academic editor and, where applicable, the Editor-in-Chief. The editorial decision is based on the manuscript, research or review evidence, scholarly contribution, reviewer reports, author responses, revised files, research-integrity requirements, and applicable AAAR policies.
Manuscripts that clearly fall outside the current Aims & Scope, fail to meet one of the two recognized manuscript types, lack adequate scholarly contribution, contain serious research-integrity concerns, or do not satisfy essential submission requirements may be declined during initial editorial screening without external peer review.
Open Access, Copyright & Article Processing Charge
AAAR provides immediate Open Access to published scholarly articles without subscription charges. Authors retain copyright, and published articles are distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-SA 4.0), subject to appropriate attribution, the ShareAlike requirement, and any applicable third-party rights.
For an accepted manuscript where at least one author is institutionally affiliated with an institution in Indonesia, the current standard AAAR Article Processing Charge is IDR 100,000 per accepted manuscript.
Where all authors are institutionally affiliated exclusively with institutions outside Indonesia, the manuscript receives a full APC waiver / IDR 0. Institutional affiliation determines APC or waiver eligibility, rather than nationality, citizenship, residence, country of birth, or another personal characteristic. Mixed authorship including at least one Indonesian institutional affiliation is subject to the standard APC.
No APC is payable before final scientific-editorial acceptance. The Editorial Office verifies the applicable APC or waiver after acceptance. Where payment applies, an official AAAR invoice provides the authorized payment instructions. APC payment, ability to pay, waiver eligibility, or waiver status does not influence screening, reviewer selection, peer review, revision requirements, or scientific-editorial decisions.
AAAR does not charge a mandatory submission fee, peer-review fee, page charge, color-figure charge, mandatory language-editing fee, or separate withdrawal fee. Authors are not required to purchase commercial language editing, proofreading, formatting, consulting, or editorial assistance as a condition of manuscript consideration or acceptance.
Previously issued official invoices and agreed payment terms are not changed retroactively merely because the current APC policy differs from an earlier administrative arrangement. Authors should consult the current APC Policy for payment, waiver administration, withdrawal, refund, and payment-security information.
Publication Model & Ethics
AAAR publishes original scholarly research and literature reviews through its official Open Access journal platform in accordance with its declared publication frequency, applicable volume and issue arrangements, scientific-editorial procedures, and publication-ethics requirements. The journal's official publication records determine the relevant issue assignments, publication dates, bibliographic information, and DOI metadata.
Publication Schedule: AAAR follows its officially established publication schedule and assigns articles to the appropriate annual volume and numbered issue. Manuscript acceptance, APC administration, production preparation, and formal publication are distinct activities. Any current or revised publication arrangements must be implemented without retrospectively altering valid historical publication records.
Editorial and Publication Processing: Manuscript submissions, editorial screening, independent peer review, revisions, scientific-editorial decisions, copyediting, proofreading, metadata verification, and production preparation proceed in accordance with the journal's applicable workflow. Final publication follows completion of all required scientific-editorial, administrative, and production procedures.
Volume and Issue Assignment: Publication-ready manuscripts are assigned to the applicable official volume and numbered issue. Issue designations, formal publication dates, DOI records, and bibliographic metadata must reflect the journal's actual scholarly and production records rather than artificial or retrospectively assigned information.
Version of Record: The formally published article represents the journal's authoritative Version of Record. Its bibliographic information, DOI where applicable, publication date, volume and issue assignment, and other relevant metadata must be accurate, traceable, and consistent with the journal's official publication record.
Historical Record Protection: Previously published volume and issue assignments, article publication dates, pagination, metadata, bibliographic information, DOI records, and established citations remain unchanged. Changes to current editorial, publication, or administrative requirements must not retrospectively reclassify valid historical scholarly records.
Publication Ethics: Authors must comply with AAAR policies concerning originality, authorship and contributorship, conflicts of interest, research ethics, informed consent, data integrity, transparency, confidentiality, citation integrity, Generative AI use, independent peer review, corrections, Expressions of Concern, retractions, and other matters affecting responsible scholarly publication.
Before Submission & Journal Contact
Before submitting to AAAR, authors should verify scope eligibility, select the correct manuscript type, prepare the current official manuscript template, complete the separate Title Page, remove all identifying information from the blinded manuscript, verify the abstract and keywords, reconcile citations with the reference list, confirm the accuracy of data and analytical results, and complete all applicable research-ethics and publication declarations.
Authors should ensure that every coauthor has approved the submission and authorship order, that the manuscript is not simultaneously under consideration elsewhere, that relevant third-party permissions are in place, and that all required OJS metadata are accurate and consistent with the separate Title Page. Formal submission takes place only through the official AAAR OJS platform.
Principal Editorial Contact: Matters requiring scientific-editorial attention may be directed to the Editor-in-Chief, Suham Cahyono, through the journal's official editorial communication channels.
Journal & Administrative Support: Questions about submission administration, editorial correspondence, manuscript files, OJS access, and applicable journal procedures may be directed to the Managing Editor, Muslim Muslim, at advancesresearch@gmail.com.
Administrative WhatsApp: +62 821 9454 8786. Administrative communication does not replace formal manuscript submission or the official scholarly evaluation and editorial-decision process conducted through OJS.
AI Tools Usage Policy
AAAR requires transparent disclosure of substantive generative-AI assistance, independent human verification, and protection of confidential research and editorial materials.
Read Responsible AI Guidance
AI Tools Usage Policy
Policy on the Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence and AI-Assisted Technologies
Advances in Applied Accounting Research (AAAR)
Publisher: Yayasan Pendidikan Bukhari Dwi Muslim
Advances in Applied Accounting Research (AAAR) recognizes the growing role of artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-assisted technologies in scholarly communication, research methods, data analysis, and manuscript preparation. Such technologies may support legitimate academic activities but must be used responsibly, transparently, and consistently with research integrity and publication ethics.
This policy establishes the responsibilities of authors, editors, peer reviewers, and editorial personnel. AI-assisted technologies must not replace genuine human intellectual contributions, independent scholarly judgment, ethical research practices, confidentiality, or accountability for published findings.
1. General Principles and Policy Scope
This policy applies to manuscript submissions, revisions, editorial screening, peer review, publication preparation, and post-publication activities conducted by AAAR.
The policy applies equally to all scholarly fields expressly recognized within the journal's current Aims & Scope. AI-related requirements do not create an additional subject-area restriction or require manuscripts to include an HRM or workforce variable when their actual subject is already within the journal's scope.
- Human accountability. Authors, reviewers, and editors remain personally responsible for their intellectual contributions, assessments, recommendations, and editorial decisions.
- Transparency. Substantive generative AI assistance must be accurately disclosed whenever required by this policy.
- Scholarly integrity. AI-assisted research and writing must not produce fabricated evidence, misleading interpretations, unsupported claims, false citations, or plagiarized content.
- Research ethics. The use of AI must respect informed consent, institutional approval, participant rights, organizational confidentiality, and applicable data-protection requirements.
- Independent peer review. AI-generated evaluations must not substitute for assessments performed by qualified independent human reviewers.
- Editorial independence. Scientific evaluation and publication decisions must remain under authorized human editorial responsibility.
AI-assisted technologies include generative language models, AI-based writing and coding assistants, automated content-generation tools, and technologies capable of generating or materially transforming research-related content. Routine conventional software functions are distinguished from substantive generative AI assistance.
2. AI Usage Policy for Authors
2.1. Authorship and Intellectual Responsibility
AI systems cannot qualify as authors or co-authors because they cannot accept responsibility for scholarly work, approve a final manuscript, disclose conflicts of interest, or respond to research-integrity concerns.
All authors must make genuine intellectual contributions, approve the manuscript, and accept responsibility for its accuracy, originality, theoretical grounding, research methodology, interpretation, references, and conclusions.
The use of AI assistance does not diminish the responsibility of human authors or replace the journal's authorship and CRediT contributorship requirements.
2.2. Permitted Uses of AI
Authors may use AI-assisted technologies for the following purposes, provided that appropriate verification and disclosure requirements are satisfied:
- Language editing. Improving grammar, spelling, sentence structure, clarity, and academic readability without changing the substantive meaning of the research.
- Translation assistance. Translating an author-prepared manuscript draft into English, provided the authors independently verify terminology, conceptual equivalence, methodological accuracy, and the translated arguments.
- Technical and programming support. Assisting with the preparation or debugging of statistical, analytical, computational, and visualization scripts, with independent testing and validation of all resulting outputs.
- Research-related AI methods. Using AI as a research instrument, computational method, analytical system, or research object where appropriately justified, ethically approved where required, transparently reported, and independently evaluated.
- Explanatory graphics. Developing conceptual diagrams or non-deceptive illustrative materials where their use is appropriate, their meaning is accurate, and relevant disclosure and intellectual-property requirements are satisfied.
2.3. Prohibited Uses of AI
Authors must not use AI to:
- Delegate the central scientific argument, literature synthesis, interpretation of findings, or conclusions to an AI system without genuine independent scholarly work and verification.
- Fabricate research participants, employee responses, questionnaire data, interview transcripts, organizational records, performance indicators, or statistical results.
- Generate fictitious financial records, accounting transactions, organizational case evidence, financial statements, or interviews and misrepresent them as authentic research data.
- Manipulate research images, tables, charts, figures, or analytical outputs in a manner that misrepresents actual evidence.
- Include fictitious or unverified scholarly publications, quotations, bibliographic information, or DOI records.
- Upload identifiable participant data, confidential employee records, private interview materials, or restricted organizational information to unauthorized or insecure AI services.
- Present predominantly AI-generated scholarly material as an original human contribution without sufficient independent intellectual work, verification, and disclosure.
2.4. Verification of Evidence and References
Authors must verify all factual claims, theoretical interpretations, statistical results, quotations, citations, and references introduced or modified through AI assistance.
AI-generated bibliographic suggestions must not be treated as confirmed scholarly sources. Authors must verify original publications, source relevance, author details, publication metadata, and DOI identifiers before citing them.
All citations and references must follow the journal's APA 7th edition requirements. The correspondence between in-text citations and the reference list must be checked in both directions.
AI-assisted analytical outputs must be validated against actual datasets, appropriate research procedures, and defensible methodological standards.
2.5. Research Papers and Literature Review Papers
The requirements of this policy apply to both manuscript types accepted by AAAR: Research Paper and Literature Review Paper.
Research designs, analytical techniques, bibliometric procedures, and AI-supported methods do not constitute additional manuscript types.
For Literature Review Papers, authors must independently verify the identification, selection, assessment, and synthesis of relevant publications. AI-generated summaries must not substitute for critical engagement with original scholarly sources.
Where AI forms part of a legitimate research or review methodology, authors must document the system's methodological role, relevant configuration, validation procedures, limitations, and reproducibility considerations, where applicable.
3. AI Usage Policy for Editors
3.1. Human-Led Editorial Decision Making
All scientific-editorial decisions must be made by authorized human editors. AI systems must not independently determine acceptance, rejection, revision requirements, or the scientific merit of a submission.
Editors must assess manuscripts within the recognized AAAR Aims & Scope according to scholarly merit, research integrity, methodological appropriateness, and independent peer-review evidence.
3.2. Permitted Administrative Assistance
Where confidentiality, authorization, and appropriate oversight are assured, editors may use automated technologies to:
- Check manuscript formatting, required submission components, declarations, and administrative compliance.
- Support secure similarity screening and preliminary reference-integrity checks, subject to human examination.
- Identify subject or methodological expertise and potential peer reviewers using appropriately accessible academic information.
- Improve language quality in routine editorial correspondence, invitations, and administrative communications.
- Support internal administrative checklists and workflow organization without disclosing protected submission information to unauthorized services.
3.3. Editorial Restrictions
Editors must not:
- Upload confidential manuscripts, unpublished data, participant information, review reports, or editorial correspondence to public or insecure AI systems.
- Delegate substantive scientific evaluation or publication decisions to generative AI.
- Reject a submission solely because an AI detector reports a numerical probability of AI-generated content.
- Treat AI-generated scientific comments, bibliographic claims, methodological criticisms, or recommendations as verified findings without independent assessment.
- Use external automated services in a manner that compromises participant confidentiality, intellectual property, or the integrity of peer review.
3.4. Editorial Oversight
When automated screening indicates a potential integrity problem, the responsible editor must evaluate the supporting evidence and seek appropriate clarification.
AI-detection scores and similarity percentages are preliminary screening indicators, not independent proof of misconduct.
Eligible submissions must continue through AAAR's double-anonymous peer-review process, normally involving at least two independent qualified human reviewers.
4. AI Usage Policy for Peer Reviewers
4.1. Independent Expert Judgment
Peer reviewers are selected for their subject knowledge, methodological competence, academic experience, and ability to provide an independent evaluation of the submitted research.
Every review report must represent the reviewer's own critical assessment. The responsibility for evaluating scientific quality, theoretical contribution, methodology, evidence, and conclusions cannot be transferred to an AI system.
4.2. Permitted Limited Assistance
Reviewers may use AI-assisted tools to improve grammar, spelling, clarity, or translation of comments independently written by the reviewer.
Such assistance must not disclose the manuscript, unpublished findings, participant information, confidential editorial correspondence, or identifiable submission content to an unauthorized AI platform.
4.3. Prohibited Reviewer Practices
- Uploading a manuscript, abstract, tables, figures, interview materials, datasets, or manuscript extracts to public or insecure AI services.
- Requesting AI to produce a complete peer-review report or substitute for independent scholarly analysis.
- Delegating the identification of methodological weaknesses, interpretation of findings, or publication recommendations to an automated system without independent evaluation.
- Submitting AI-generated criticisms based on invented references, unsupported arguments, or unexamined manuscript content.
- Using privileged manuscript information for personal, professional, competitive, commercial, or unrelated research purposes.
4.4. Reporting Suspected AI Misuse
Reviewers who identify credible indications of fabricated references, invented datasets, manipulated findings, or undisclosed substantive AI misuse must communicate their concerns confidentially to the responsible editor.
Concerns should be supported by specific evidence. Reviewers must not independently accuse authors, contact their employers, or treat AI detector outputs as definitive evidence of misconduct.
5. Confidentiality, Data Security and Research Ethics
AAAR requires the protection of research participants, institutional records, unpublished manuscripts, restricted datasets, and confidential editorial materials.
These responsibilities are particularly important in studies involving confidential accounting records, financial statements, corporate reporting, banking information, tax records, client details, institutional records, organizational information, research participants, or other sensitive data.
- Participant protection. Identifiable information and sensitive participant records must be protected in accordance with applicable ethical and legal requirements.
- Organizational confidentiality. Confidential accounting records, financial or tax information, internal organizational documents, client data, and restricted institutional datasets must not be disclosed without appropriate authority.
- External AI systems. Confidential data and manuscripts must not be uploaded to public or insecure AI services. Proposed external processing involving confidential content requires prior explicit editorial authorization and adequate safeguards.
- Research ethics compliance. Authors must respect applicable ethical approval, informed consent, participant privacy, data-use authorization, and institutional permission requirements.
- Incident reporting. Suspected unauthorized disclosure, privacy breaches, or misuse of protected research material must be reported promptly through appropriate editorial or institutional channels.
When AI-generated responses, synthetic organizational scenarios, or simulated observations are legitimately investigated as research objects, authors must identify their artificial origin, explain the study procedures, and avoid presenting them as genuine participant data.
6. Declaration and Disclosure of AI Use
6.1. When Disclosure Is Required
Routine spelling correction, conventional grammar checking, formatting, or straightforward language correction without substantive content generation does not normally require a separate AI declaration.
Substantive use of generative AI must be disclosed, including extensive language restructuring, translation of manuscript drafts, generation or debugging of analytical code, AI-assisted research procedures, and other material assistance affecting manuscript preparation or analysis.
6.2. Where the Declaration Must Be Placed
Mandatory submission placement: The AI-use declaration must be included in the separate Title Page & Author Information Form.
AAAR applies double-anonymous peer review. Author-identifying declarations must not appear in the blinded manuscript.
Where AI or automated technologies materially contribute to research design, data collection, coding, analysis, experimental procedures, or literature-review methodology, sufficient non-identifying methodological information must also be included in the blinded manuscript.
This requirement does not introduce a third mandatory file at initial submission. The separate Title Page and the blinded manuscript remain the two required submission documents.
6.3. Required Declaration Components
- Tool identification: Name, developer, and relevant model or version where identifiable.
- Purpose and scope: A specific explanation of which activities, manuscript sections, or research procedures were assisted by AI.
- Human verification: Confirmation that the authors independently examined, corrected, tested, and validated the relevant AI-assisted outputs.
- Human responsibility: Confirmation that the authors accept full responsibility for originality, research integrity, accuracy, and scientific conclusions.
6.4. Standard Declaration Templates
A. Language Editing or Translation
The authors used [AI tool, developer, and version] to assist with [describe the language editing or translation activities] during manuscript preparation. All assisted content was subsequently reviewed and corrected by the authors to preserve the intended scholarly meaning. The authors verified the final text and accept full responsibility for its accuracy, originality, and integrity.
B. Technical or Coding Assistance
The authors used [AI tool, developer, and version] to assist with [describe the technical or programming task]. Relevant procedures are reported in the Research Methodology section. All assisted code, calculations, and analytical outputs were independently tested and verified against the study data. The authors remain fully responsible for the validity of the findings.
C. AI as Part of a Research Method
The study employed [AI system or model] for [specific research procedure]. The methodological role, relevant configuration, validation procedures, ethical considerations, and limitations are described in the manuscript. The authors independently assessed the outputs and accept full responsibility for the reliability and interpretation of the research.
D. Optional Declaration of No Substantive AI Use
The authors declare that no substantive generative AI assistance was used in the intellectual development, analysis, interpretation, or preparation of this manuscript beyond routine conventional editing functions, where applicable.
Authors must adapt these statements to reflect their actual practices. Disclosure does not authorize activities otherwise prohibited under the journal's research integrity and publication ethics policies.
7. Policy Violations, Investigation and Sanctions
7.1. Fair Investigation and Due Process
Suspected AI-related misconduct must be addressed through an objective, evidence-based, and proportionate editorial procedure consistent with applicable publication-ethics requirements.
AI-detection scores, automated classifications, or unsupported allegations are not sufficient grounds for a finding of misconduct.
AAAR may examine relevant manuscript materials, research records, cited sources, methodological documentation, AI-use declarations, and explanations from the concerned parties.
Before disciplinary action is imposed, the concerned party should receive a reasonable opportunity to respond, subject to appropriate confidentiality and conflict-of-interest safeguards.
7.2. Possible Actions Concerning Authors
- Minor disclosure deficiencies. Authors may be requested to complete or correct an omitted AI-use declaration when the underlying assistance was permitted and the reliability of the research is not compromised.
- Materially deficient submissions. Where verified AI misuse compromises scientific originality, citation accuracy, methodological integrity, or research reliability, the journal may require substantive correction or reject the manuscript.
- Serious research misconduct. Established fabrication, falsification, deliberate misrepresentation, severe confidentiality violations, or fundamentally unreliable published findings may result in retraction and proportionate additional measures, including institutional notification or submission restrictions where justified.
7.3. Possible Actions Concerning Reviewers
A peer-review report generated without independent scholarly assessment, or prepared through a serious breach of manuscript confidentiality, may be invalidated and excluded from editorial decision-making.
Depending on the established facts and severity, the journal may issue a formal warning, terminate an assignment, or remove the individual from its active reviewer pool.
7.4. Possible Actions Concerning Editors
Verified editorial misuse may lead to reassignment of a manuscript, withdrawal of handling authority, formal corrective action, or review of editorial appointment status.
An editor with a relevant conflict of interest must not determine the outcome of an investigation involving their own conduct.
7.5. Post-Publication Actions
When concerns are identified after publication, AAAR may request an author explanation, review supporting research documentation, consult independent specialists, and take appropriate editorial action.
Depending on the evidence and severity of the issue, the journal may publish a correction, Expression of Concern, or retraction.
Post-publication notices must be transparent and linked to the original publication. The Version of Record must not be silently modified to conceal material research-integrity concerns.
8. Responsibilities and Implementation
| Party | Main Responsibility | AI-Related Requirement |
|---|---|---|
| Authors | Produce original, ethical, and verifiable scholarship. | Verify outputs, safeguard participants and research data, and disclose substantive AI use. |
| Reviewers | Provide independent and competent scholarly evaluation. | Protect confidentiality and do not delegate scientific judgment to AI. |
| Editors | Maintain impartial and independent editorial decisions. | Independently assess automated screening results and retain human decision authority. |
| Editorial Office | Maintain submissions, administrative records, and communication procedures. | Apply appropriate access controls, confidentiality measures, and documentation requirements. |
This policy complements the journal's existing publication-ethics, authorship, peer-review, plagiarism, confidentiality, research ethics, complaints, and post-publication policies.
This dedicated AI-policy page is prepared from AAAR's existing research-integrity and publication-ethics requirements. Its adoption as a separate official policy and its effective date must be confirmed by the Editorial Office before publication. Until then, the existing publication-ethics page remains authoritative.
Historical manuscripts, editorial records, valid publications, and bibliographic information are not automatically invalidated by subsequent policy changes. Concerns about earlier publications must be evaluated on their merits under applicable research-integrity procedures.
Related Journal Policies
For Authors | For Reviewers | Policies & Publication Ethics
For policy clarification, confidential research-integrity concerns, or reports of suspected AI misuse, contact: advancesresearch@gmail.com
Advances in Applied Accounting Research (AAAR)
Published by Yayasan Pendidikan Bukhari Dwi Muslim.
Responsible AI use, scholarly independence, research integrity, participant protection, and publication transparency.
Policies & Publication Ethics
AAAR applies double-anonymous peer review, research-integrity safeguards, and Open Access under CC BY-SA 4.0. Its published ethics provisions are the authoritative policy.
Read Full Publication Ethics
Policies & Publication Ethics
Advances in Applied Accounting Research (AAAR) is committed to responsible scholarly publishing, independent academic evaluation, research integrity, transparent editorial procedures, and the protection of the permanent scholarly record. The journal's ethical framework is informed by internationally recognized good publication practices, including relevant guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
These responsibilities apply to authors, reviewers, editors, editorial administrators, production personnel, and Yayasan Pendidikan Bukhari Dwi Muslim as the journal's publisher. Every participant is expected to act with academic honesty, professional fairness, respect for confidentiality, appropriate acknowledgment of intellectual contributions, and accountability for assigned responsibilities.
Editorial evaluation considers a manuscript's relevance to the current AAAR Aims & Scope, originality, intellectual contribution, theoretical or conceptual grounding, methodological appropriateness, research transparency, validity of evidence, scholarly interpretation, and compliance with the journal's submission and publication requirements.
Scope Principle: AAAR welcomes rigorous applied accounting research covering financial accounting and reporting, management accounting, public-sector accounting, corporate governance, internal control, financial management, accounting standards, sustainability and ESG accounting, green finance, digital accounting, accounting information systems, professional accounting practice, and related interdisciplinary contributions recognized in its current Aims & Scope. An article is evaluated according to its substantive accounting-related scholarly contribution rather than the presence of a particular auditing, taxation, or financial variable.
Editorial Independence: Academic judgments must remain independent of inappropriate financial, commercial, institutional, political, personal, or other external influences. APC payment, waiver eligibility, advertising, sponsorship, institutional relationships, and publisher administration cannot determine acceptance or rejection.
Research & Publication Misconduct
AAAR does not accept research or publication practices that intentionally or materially distort the scientific record. Manuscripts must communicate authentic research procedures, credible evidence, accurate analytical outcomes, and conclusions that can reasonably be supported by the reported work.
Unacceptable practices include plagiarism, unattributed appropriation of intellectual work, fabricated or falsified evidence, misleading alteration of data or analytical results, undisclosed duplicate publication, concurrent submission to multiple journals, inappropriate text recycling, manipulation of citations, fabricated references, fraudulent reviewer identities, peer-review interference, and unauthorized changes to authorship.
False statements concerning ethics approval, informed consent, institutional authorization, research permissions, data availability, funding, conflicts of interest, or research procedures are also unacceptable. Authors must not present invented analyses, fabricated statistical outputs, fictitious interviews, nonexistent datasets, or unverified automated outputs as genuine scientific findings.
Where a credible concern arises, the Editorial Office may request clarification, relevant research records, supporting documentation, or an independent scholarly assessment. The nature of the response depends on the available evidence, the seriousness of the concern, the manuscript's publication stage, and the need for procedural fairness.
Authorship & Contributorship
Authorship must represent substantial intellectual involvement in the reported research or literature review. Authors are expected to participate meaningfully in developing the research, collecting or interpreting evidence, preparing or critically revising the manuscript, approving its final version, and accepting responsibility for the integrity of their scholarly contributions.
Individuals who provide administrative assistance, financial support, technical services, routine supervision, language assistance, or other contributions that do not satisfy authorship requirements should be recognized through appropriate acknowledgements rather than being assigned authorship without justification. Ghost, guest, and gift authorship are prohibited.
CRediT Contributions: AAAR requires accurate contributor-role information using the CRediT Contributor Roles Taxonomy. Contributions are documented in the separate Title Page & Author Information Form and must reflect actual work performed by the identified authors.
A corresponding author must be identified and must provide a valid ORCID iD. Other authors should supply ORCID identifiers where available. The corresponding author coordinates submission information, author approvals, required declarations, journal correspondence, and communication of manuscript decisions to co-authors.
Title Page & Author Confirmation: Author names, affiliations, contribution statements, approval confirmations, originality declarations, funding information, conflicts of interest, and other relevant publication declarations are recorded in the separate Title Page. A separate author-declaration letter is not ordinarily required unless requested for a specific editorial or research-integrity purpose.
Requests to add, remove, or rearrange authors must include a reasoned explanation and confirmation from the affected authors. The responsible editor evaluates the request in relation to the available evidence, the contribution record, authorship accountability, and the stage of manuscript processing.
After publication, a material correction to authorship must be addressed through an appropriate, transparent scholarly-record procedure. Author changes must not be made secretly or used to conceal earlier authorship disputes or editorial decisions.
Manuscript Types & Peer Review Policy
AAAR accepts exactly two manuscript types: Research Paper and Literature Review Paper. Quantitative, qualitative, mixed-method, conceptual, methodological, econometric, case-based, and other research approaches describe the design or intellectual contribution of an eligible manuscript; they do not constitute additional manuscript categories.
A Research Paper presents original research undertaken through a defensible and adequately documented design. A Literature Review Paper provides meaningful synthesis of scholarly literature through a clearly identified and sufficiently transparent review approach. Both manuscript types must demonstrate intellectual merit, credible evidence, logical argumentation, and a substantive contribution within the journal's Aims & Scope.
AAAR applies double-anonymous peer review. Authors submit a Blinded Manuscript separately from the Title Page & Author Information Form. Identifying author information is withheld from independent reviewers, while reviewer identities remain confidential to authors under the applicable editorial workflow.
Every new submission undergoes initial editorial screening. Screening considers journal scope, manuscript-type eligibility, originality, methodological adequacy, research integrity, scholarly contribution, presentation quality, and submission compliance. The journal may decline a manuscript before external review when it does not satisfy essential editorial requirements.
Manuscripts proceeding to external peer review are normally evaluated by at least two independent reviewers whose scholarly expertise is relevant to the research topic, conceptual framework, methodological approach, or review methodology.
Research Paper Assessment: Reviewers consider the research question, theoretical or conceptual foundation, research design, sampling and data selection, instruments, evidence quality, analytical validity, findings, interpretation, limitations, and theoretical or practical implications. Expectations are applied according to the actual methodology rather than a single preferred statistical technique.
Literature Review Paper Assessment: Reviewers consider the review objective, stated review design, identification and selection of literature, transparency of relevant procedures, critical evaluation, synthesis, conceptual development, scholarly integration, limitations, and the extent to which conclusions are supported by the reviewed literature.
An article must not claim to follow a systematic, scoping, PRISMA-based, bibliometric, meta-analytical, or other specialized review method unless that method was actually undertaken and sufficiently reported. Descriptive bibliometric output alone does not establish a substantive literature-review contribution without meaningful scholarly interpretation.
Editorial Workflow: Submission → Editorial Screening → Independent Peer Review → Revision → Post-Revision Verification → Final Editorial Decision.
Reviewer recommendations may include acceptance, minor revision, major revision, or rejection. Such recommendations inform editorial judgment but do not automatically determine the final decision. Where reports materially disagree, the responsible academic editor may seek clarification or arrange an additional independent review.
Reviewer Confidentiality: Reviewers must disclose relevant conflicts, maintain manuscript confidentiality, provide objective and constructive reports, and avoid unauthorized communication with authors. Manuscript files and unpublished findings must not be disclosed, commercially exploited, or delegated to another reviewer without editorial authorization.
Originality, Plagiarism & Reference Integrity
Authors must submit original scholarly material that has not been published previously in substantially the same form or simultaneously offered for publication to another journal. All borrowed concepts, quotations, methods, data, illustrations, tables, instruments, and other intellectual materials must receive appropriate attribution.
Similarity Screening: AAAR applies a maximum overall similarity threshold of 15% under its harmonized editorial screening standard. Appropriate similarity-detection software may be used to examine submitted manuscripts for potentially problematic textual overlap.
A similarity score is not, by itself, a conclusive plagiarism finding. Editorial evaluation must consider the origin, extent, nature, placement, quotation status, and context of matching passages. A manuscript may contain unacceptable plagiarism even when the numerical similarity score falls below the stated threshold.
Authors must distinguish legitimate reuse of previously published knowledge from undisclosed reproduction of their own or another person's work. Material duplication, inappropriate text recycling, redundant publication, and misleadingly repackaged findings may result in requests for clarification, revision, rejection, or relevant post-publication measures.
Reference Integrity: AAAR requires APA 7th edition for citations and references. Authors must verify that cited publications exist, bibliographic information is accurate, DOI identifiers correspond to the cited works, and in-text citations match the reference list. Fictitious, hallucinated, fabricated, or unverifiable sources must not be presented as legitimate scholarly references.
Conflicts of Interest
A conflict of interest exists when financial, professional, institutional, collaborative, supervisory, academic, competitive, or personal circumstances may influence, or reasonably appear to influence, impartial scholarly judgment. Relevant conflicts must be disclosed and managed rather than concealed.
Authors: Authors must disclose relevant financial and non-financial interests, including relationships with funding organizations, institutions, research sponsors, or other parties with an interest in the reported work. Where no material conflict exists, an explicit statement to that effect must be provided in the separate Title Page.
Reviewers: Reviewers must promptly identify relationships or circumstances that could compromise independent evaluation. Where a material conflict cannot be adequately managed, the reviewer must decline or withdraw from the assignment.
Editors: Editors must not oversee a manuscript when their involvement creates a material conflict of interest. In such cases, the manuscript should be assigned to a suitably qualified academic editor who is able to manage the review and decision process independently.
Editor-Authored Manuscripts: Editors submitting their own scholarly work must not manage reviewer selection, access confidential assessment information, evaluate their own revisions, or participate in the final editorial decision. Editorial-board membership does not provide preferential treatment or guarantee acceptance.
Generative AI & Automated Tools
Generative AI systems and automated applications cannot be credited as authors because they cannot provide informed approval, assume legal or ethical responsibility, or be held accountable for published scholarly work. Human authors remain responsible for all manuscript content and research conclusions.
Disclosure: Substantive AI-assisted activities beyond ordinary spelling, grammar, formatting, or straightforward language correction must be disclosed through the separate Title Page & Author Information Form. The disclosure should describe the relevant system and the purpose for which it was used.
When artificial intelligence, machine learning, automated classification, large language models, or related computational technologies constitute part of the research methodology, data analysis, or literature-review process, the methodological procedures must be reported with sufficient clarity for independent academic evaluation.
AI-assisted numerical results, accounting interpretations, financial calculations, references, quotations, literature classifications, and factual assertions must be independently checked. Automated outputs must not be portrayed as verified empirical results unless supported by appropriate underlying evidence and valid procedures.
Images & Research Evidence: AI-generated or materially altered graphics must not be presented deceptively as original empirical, documentary, observational, or photographic evidence. Appropriate explanatory illustrations may be considered when their nature and use are accurately disclosed.
Editorial Confidentiality: Reviewers and editors must not expose unpublished manuscripts, identifiable author records, confidential reviewer reports, restricted datasets, or private editorial communication to external AI services when suitable confidentiality and information-protection safeguards cannot be assured. Automated assistance does not replace human editorial responsibility.
Research Ethics, Consent & Permissions
Applied accounting research may involve employees, accountants, auditors, financial managers, public officials, organizational respondents, confidential corporate records, commercially sensitive financial information, or identifiable research participants. Authors must comply with applicable institutional, disciplinary, ethical, legal, and data-protection requirements.
Where applicable, ethical approval, informed consent, institutional permission, organizational authorization, restricted-data access, and related compliance information must be accurately documented in the separate Title Page. Authors may be asked to provide appropriate verification of these declarations.
During double-anonymous review, manuscripts should explain the relevant ethical safeguards and research procedures without unnecessarily revealing author identities, participating organizations, or confidential information. Sufficient methodological transparency must be maintained for reviewers to assess ethical and scholarly adequacy.
Research involving identifiable individuals requires appropriate attention to privacy, informed participation, secure information handling, and consent for publication where relevant. Particular care is required where participants or organizations may face reputational, professional, financial, or other foreseeable risks arising from disclosure.
Ethical Accuracy: Approval numbers, consent statements, institutional permissions, and research-authorization records must not be fabricated. When formal ethics approval is not required under the applicable framework, authors must accurately explain that position if clarification is requested.
Data, Transparency & Reproducibility
AAAR encourages research reporting that enables readers and reviewers to understand how conclusions were developed from the relevant evidence. Authors should document research questions, theoretical foundations, data sources, selection procedures, analytical methods, assumptions, and material limitations with appropriate methodological detail.
Accounting research based on surveys, interviews, financial statements, organizational records, public databases, experiments, case studies, archival materials, or other evidence must describe the relevant collection, selection, processing, and analytical procedures sufficiently for meaningful scholarly assessment.
Authors should retain applicable data, research instruments, analytical documentation, coding records, computational materials, review-search records, and other supporting evidence needed to address legitimate questions about the reported work. Where reasonable and permitted, suitable supporting materials are encouraged to be deposited in recognized research repositories.
Restrictions arising from participant confidentiality, private company records, financial secrecy, contractual obligations, proprietary accounting data, intellectual property, or legal requirements must be respected. The journal does not require public disclosure of protected information where such disclosure would be unethical or unlawful.
Data Availability Statement: Authors must provide an accurate declaration in the separate Title Page identifying whether supporting data or materials are publicly accessible, available on reasonable request, included in supporting files, restricted for legitimate reasons, or not applicable to the reported study. The declaration must correspond to the actual status of the evidence.
Funding & Acknowledgements
Authors must accurately identify grants, institutional support, research sponsorships, financial assistance, or other material funding arrangements relevant to the reported work. Funding information should include appropriate institutional or grant identifiers where applicable and must not imply support that was not actually provided.
Individuals and institutions that supplied meaningful assistance without meeting authorship requirements may be acknowledged appropriately. Such recognition must fairly represent the contribution and respect applicable consent and confidentiality requirements.
Funding and acknowledgment information that reveals author identities must be placed in the separate Title Page during double-anonymous review. Appropriate information may be transferred to the public article record after acceptance through authorized editorial and production procedures.
Third-Party Materials & Permissions
Authors are responsible for determining whether research instruments, questionnaires, accounting datasets, proprietary databases, financial reports, figures, tables, measurement scales, copyrighted extracts, software outputs, or other external materials require permission, acknowledgment, or compliance with particular licensing terms.
Where authorization is necessary, it must be obtained before publication. Appropriate source acknowledgment, licensing information, and permission documentation must be provided through the relevant manuscript or administrative materials.
The publication license applied to an AAAR article does not automatically remove copyright or contractual restrictions from third-party materials expressly excluded from that license. Authors must make such limitations clear where appropriate and supply reasonable supporting documentation if requested.
Complaints & Appeals
AAAR receives legitimate concerns relating to manuscript evaluation, reviewer conduct, editorial procedures, conflicts of interest, publication ethics, administrative handling, confidentiality, research integrity, and the accuracy of published scholarly content. Complaints and appeals are assessed in a professional manner with due regard for evidence, fairness, and confidentiality.
An editorial appeal should identify the relevant manuscript, the disputed decision, the grounds for requesting reconsideration, and any material information supporting the request. An apparent procedural irregularity, significant factual error, overlooked evidence, or unmanaged conflict of interest may warrant additional editorial examination.
An author's disagreement with an unfavorable assessment does not, by itself, establish grounds for reversing a decision. Any reconsideration must take account of the complete manuscript record and remain under authorized independent academic editorial judgment.
Ethics, Complaints & Appeals Contact: The Managing Editor coordinates relevant correspondence through advancesresearch@gmail.com. Matters requiring principal academic editorial authority are referred to the Editor-in-Chief or another appropriately authorized independent editor.
Handling Allegations of Research Misconduct
AAAR considers credible allegations of research or publication misconduct through an evidence-based and proportionate process. The submission of a complaint does not constitute proof that the alleged conduct occurred, and the journal seeks to distinguish substantiated findings from unresolved concerns.
Receipt & Preliminary Assessment: The Editorial Office records the concern, reviews the available supporting information, and considers whether it falls within the journal's responsibility. Further examination is initiated when the circumstances justify an appropriate response.
Conflict-of-Interest Management: Editors or other individuals involved in handling an allegation must disclose relevant conflicts. Where impartiality may reasonably be compromised, responsibility is transferred to an appropriate independent person or editorial authority.
Evidence & Clarification: Relevant parties may be invited to explain the matter and provide supporting records, source data, permissions, research documentation, approval information, correspondence, or other material necessary for a fair assessment.
Independent Consultation: The journal may obtain suitable advice from independent scholars, research-integrity specialists, ethics committees, relevant institutions, publishers, funders, or other competent bodies when the nature of the allegation requires additional expertise.
Editorial Determination: The resulting action depends on the evidence and publication stage. Possible outcomes include no further action, clarification, additional verification, manuscript revision, rejection, a published correction, an Expression of Concern, retraction, or another proportionate scholarly-record measure.
Procedural Fairness: Confidentiality, relevant rights of affected individuals, reasonable opportunities to respond, accurate documentation, and the independence of editorial judgment should be protected throughout the handling of a misconduct concern.
Corrections, Expressions of Concern & Retractions
AAAR maintains the accuracy and traceability of its formally published research. When credible concerns arise after publication, the journal considers the most appropriate mechanism for correcting or qualifying the scholarly record without concealing relevant publication history.
Correction: A formal correction may be appropriate when a published article contains a material error that requires public clarification but does not fundamentally undermine the reliability of the research. The notice should identify the affected article and explain the relevant change.
Expression of Concern: An Expression of Concern may be appropriate where serious questions exist about a publication but the relevant findings remain uncertain, incomplete, or under investigation. The notice should not imply a completed finding where the evidence is still unresolved.
Retraction: Retraction may be necessary where published findings are substantially unreliable, serious misconduct is established, unethical research materially compromises the publication, or significant duplicate publication or another major integrity problem invalidates the article's reliability.
Version of Record: Substantive changes to a published article must be handled transparently. Formal notices should be linked to the affected article and, where applicable, reflected in DOI metadata, indexing information, and the permanent scholarly record. Silent replacement must not be used to conceal material corrections or integrity concerns.
Manuscript Withdrawal: Authors may submit a formal withdrawal request before publication while their manuscript remains under consideration. They should obtain confirmation from AAAR that the manuscript is no longer under consideration before submitting it to another journal. No separate withdrawal fee is charged.
Applicable post-publication decisions may take account of relevant COPE guidance, the documented evidence, the rights of affected parties, and the overriding need to protect the reliability of scholarly publication.
Open Access, Copyright & Licensing
AAAR provides immediate Open Access to formally published scholarly articles. Readers may access the published research without subscription charges or a mandatory reader-registration requirement. The journal supports broad scholarly access, responsible knowledge sharing, and transparent dissemination of applied accounting research.
Copyright: Authors retain copyright in their scholarly work and grant AAAR the right of first publication and the permissions necessary for authorized publication, distribution, scholarly identification, and preservation.
Licensing: Under the harmonized AAAR publication standard, newly published articles are distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License (CC BY-SA 4.0). The license permits copying, redistribution, adaptation, transformation, and reuse, including commercial reuse, when appropriate attribution is provided, relevant changes are identified, and adaptations comply with the ShareAlike requirement.
Submitted Manuscript: Authors may share or deposit a submitted version through appropriate academic channels, provided that its status as an unpublished manuscript is accurately represented and applicable intellectual-property, confidentiality, and third-party requirements are respected.
Accepted Manuscript: After formal scientific-editorial acceptance, authors may deposit the accepted version, clearly identifying it as distinct from the final publication. It must not be presented as the authoritative published Version of Record.
Published Version of Record: Following publication, authors may deposit or distribute their articles in accordance with the license applicable to that article. The deposited record should identify AAAR as the original journal and provide accurate citation information, DOI, and licensing details.
Self-Archiving: AAAR does not impose a journal-specific embargo on permitted deposits of submitted, accepted, or published manuscript versions. Authors remain responsible for any applicable legal, ethical, contractual, repository, confidentiality, or third-party obligations.
Historical Licensing Integrity: Articles published under an earlier license retain their documented licensing terms. Adoption of the harmonized licensing framework does not retroactively replace the original license information attached to a previously published Version of Record.
Advertising, Revenue & Editorial Independence
AAAR separates scholarly decision-making from financial and promotional interests. APC administration, publisher funding, institutional collaboration, and any applicable advertising or sponsorship arrangements must not determine whether a manuscript receives favorable editorial consideration.
No advertiser, sponsor, institutional partner, commercial service provider, or administrative representative has authority to determine reviewer assignments, influence reviewer recommendations, purchase manuscript acceptance, override independent editorial assessment, or guarantee publication.
Any promotional activity undertaken by the journal must remain distinguishable from editorial content. The journal does not imply that academic acceptance, research quality, publication outcomes, or scholarly endorsement can be purchased through financial or institutional relationships.
Post-Publication Discussion
AAAR encourages responsible academic debate concerning published research. Constructive methodological criticism, alternative interpretations, evidence-based commentary, and identification of material errors contribute to the refinement of applied accounting scholarship.
Readers, researchers, authors, reviewers, and interested stakeholders may raise concerns concerning analytical reliability, accounting interpretation, research ethics, factual accuracy, undisclosed limitations, bibliographic information, or other matters warranting editorial consideration.
Where appropriate, the journal may request clarification from the authors, examine supporting documentation, consult independent experts, or initiate a proportionate editorial review. Any necessary published response should preserve the distinction between scholarly disagreement, correctable error, unresolved concern, and substantiated research misconduct.
APC & Post-Acceptance Governance
AAAR does not require Article Processing Charge payment at submission, editorial screening, peer review, revision, post-revision verification, or any other stage preceding final scientific-editorial acceptance. APC and waiver administration are initiated only after an authorized final acceptance decision.
Standard APC — IDR 100,000: An accepted manuscript is subject to the standard APC where at least one author has an institutional affiliation with an institution located in Indonesia.
Full APC Waiver — IDR 0: An accepted manuscript receives a full waiver where every author is affiliated exclusively with institutions outside Indonesia. Eligibility is based on institutional affiliation and not nationality, citizenship, birthplace, or personal residence.
AAAR does not impose a mandatory manuscript-submission fee, peer-review fee, page charge, separate withdrawal fee, or mandatory purchase of external editing or publication services. The applicable APC is administered according to the journal's official post-acceptance procedures.
Official Invoicing: When an APC applies, an official invoice is issued only after final editorial acceptance. Authors should use authorized payment instructions and verify any unusual invoice or payment request through the official journal communication channels. Previously issued legitimate invoices and agreed payment terms are not changed retroactively.
Post-Acceptance Workflow: Final Editorial Acceptance → APC or Waiver Verification → Post-Acceptance Administration → Copyediting → Proofreading & Production → Metadata Verification → Version of Record → Online Publication.
Production and publication preparation take place after the manuscript has satisfied the relevant scientific-editorial requirements. A post-acceptance administrator or production service cannot independently revise the scholarly findings, override authorship decisions, or resolve substantive research-integrity concerns without appropriate academic editorial authority.
Withdrawal and refund requests are handled under the official AAAR APC Policy. After payment and the commencement of substantive post-acceptance services, the APC is normally non-refundable, subject to consideration of documented payment errors or relevant journal-attributable administrative circumstances.
Financial Independence: Payment or waiver status does not determine acceptance, reviewer recommendations, publication dates, issue assignment, DOI registration, research evaluation, or scholarly outcomes. No payment constitutes a guarantee of publication.
Policy Application, Historical Record & Contact
AAAR applies its current editorial and publication policies according to their relevant requirements and applicable administrative arrangements. New or revised provisions are interpreted prospectively where appropriate and do not automatically invalidate legitimate earlier editorial decisions, publication records, financial arrangements, or scholarly commitments.
Aims & Scope: Manuscripts are evaluated in relation to the journal's applicable Aims & Scope, including financial and managerial accounting, accounting standards, public-sector accounting, financial reporting, organizational governance, sustainability and ESG accounting, accounting information systems, green finance, and related fields recognized by AAAR. Scholarly relevance is determined by the substance of the contribution.
Publication Frequency: AAAR maintains one annual volume comprising three regular numbered issues. For the historical publication framework associated with Volumes 1–4 (2023–2026), the designated periods are No. 1 October–January, No. 2 February–May, and No. 3 June–September, subject to the actual publication records documented in the journal archives.
Standardized Issue Schedule: Beginning with Volume 5 (2027), the regular publication periods are No. 1 January–April, No. 2 May–August, and No. 3 September–December. October–December 2026 constitutes the scheduled transition without creation of an additional fourth numbered issue.
Continuous Publication: AAAR adopts continuous publication prospectively from 1 September 2026 within the applicable active numbered issue and subject to the established transition. This arrangement concerns the timing of individual article release and does not reduce the required peer-review, editorial, research-integrity, or publication-production standards.
Historical Scholarly Record: Established annual volumes, published numbered issues, article titles, authorship information, actual publication dates, pagination, DOI registrations, original licensing information, and other valid bibliographic records remain part of the permanent scholarly record. Later policy revisions must not be used to retrospectively alter these records without a legitimate, transparent correction procedure.
Publication Ethics & Administrative Support: Muslim Muslim, Managing Editor, coordinates relevant administrative correspondence concerning journal procedures, complaints, appeals, research-integrity documentation, and publication-ethics matters. Official email: advancesresearch@gmail.com.
Principal Academic Editorial Contact: Suham Cahyono, Editor-in-Chief, provides senior academic editorial leadership and oversight of independent scholarly evaluation, research integrity, and decisions requiring principal editorial authority. Official academic editorial correspondence may be directed to editor@advancesinresearch.id.
Commitment to Responsible Scholarly Publishing
AAAR is committed to publishing rigorous and responsibly conducted applied accounting research through transparent editorial procedures, independent peer review, appropriate research-ethics safeguards, accurate scholarly reporting, and respect for authors, reviewers, institutions, research participants, and readers.
The journal seeks to advance reliable academic knowledge while maintaining meaningful editorial independence, responsible authorship, accurate citations and evidence, appropriate confidentiality, accessible publication, fair handling of complaints, transparent correction procedures, and the long-term integrity of the scholarly record.
Current Issue
Vol. 4 No. 3 (2026)
View All Issues