Policies & Publication Ethics
Editorial Integrity, Research Ethics & Responsible Publishing

Advances in Business & Industrial Marketing Research (ABIM) is committed to responsible scholarly publishing, editorial independence, responsible peer review, research integrity, transparency, and preservation of the scholarly record.

The journal's publication-ethics policies are informed by recognized scholarly publishing principles and relevant guidance issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) ↗ . These policies apply to authors, reviewers, editors, editorial staff, and the publisher.

 
Publication Ethics Principles
Editorial Independence
Editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit, relevance, integrity, and peer-review evidence and remain independent of financial or commercial considerations.
Research Integrity
Fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, citation manipulation, duplicate publication, and other forms of research misconduct are not acceptable.
Fair Peer Review
Peer review must be independent, confidential, objective, constructive, and free from inappropriate conflicts of interest.
Transparent Correction
Errors and integrity concerns affecting the scholarly record are addressed through appropriate corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, or other editorial actions.
Authorship & Contributorship

Authorship should accurately reflect substantial intellectual contributions to the research and manuscript. Individuals listed as authors must accept responsibility for the work and approve the final version submitted for publication.

Authorship Criteria
  1. Substantial contribution to the conception or design of the work, or acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data.
  2. Drafting the manuscript or critically revising it for significant intellectual content.
  3. Final approval of the version to be published.
  4. Agreement to be accountable for the accuracy and integrity of the work.

Contributors who do not meet authorship criteria should be acknowledged appropriately. ABIM does not permit ghost, guest, or gift authorship.

Manuscripts must include an author-contribution statement. Authors are encouraged to use the CRediT Contributor Roles Taxonomy ↗ where appropriate.

Originality, Plagiarism & Duplicate Submission

Manuscripts submitted to ABIM must represent original scholarly work and must not be simultaneously submitted to or under consideration by another journal.

Material derived from other sources must be appropriately quoted, paraphrased, cited, and attributed. Plagiarism, inappropriate text recycling, duplicate publication, redundant publication, and undisclosed substantial overlap are not acceptable.

Similarity Screening: Submitted manuscripts may be screened using Turnitin or other appropriate similarity-detection tools. The maximum overall similarity threshold is 15%. Meeting the numerical threshold does not automatically establish originality; editors evaluate the nature, location, and legitimacy of matched material.
Research & Publication Misconduct

Potential misconduct may include, but is not limited to:

  • Fabrication or falsification of data or results
  • Plagiarism or inappropriate text recycling
  • Duplicate, redundant, or simultaneous submission
  • Undisclosed image or data manipulation
  • Inappropriate authorship or contributorship
  • Citation manipulation
  • Peer-review manipulation
  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest
  • Misrepresentation of ethical approval or informed consent
  • Other conduct that materially compromises research or publication integrity
Handling Allegations of Misconduct

ABIM considers allegations concerning submitted and published work. Reports should contain sufficient information to allow the Editorial Office to understand and assess the concern.

  1. The allegation is received and initially assessed.
  2. Relevant conflicts of interest are considered.
  3. Available evidence is reviewed confidentially.
  4. The author, reviewer, editor, or other relevant party may be invited to respond.
  5. Additional expert advice or institutional clarification may be requested where necessary.
  6. The journal determines an appropriate editorial response based on available evidence.
  7. Where appropriate, the scholarly record is corrected through correction, expression of concern, retraction, or other action.

ABIM may contact relevant institutions, funding bodies, other journals, or appropriate authorities where an allegation requires investigation beyond the journal's authority.

Conflicts of Interest

Authors, reviewers, editors, and other participants in the publication process must disclose relationships or interests that could reasonably influence or appear to influence their professional judgment.

Relevant conflicts may be financial, institutional, professional, personal, collaborative, competitive, supervisory, or otherwise connected to the manuscript or its participants. Editors with relevant conflicts must not handle or make decisions on the affected manuscript.

Research Ethics & Ethical Oversight

Research involving human participants, animals, personal or confidential data, vulnerable populations, or other ethically sensitive matters must comply with applicable institutional, national, and disciplinary requirements.

  • Appropriate institutional or ethics-committee approval should be reported where required.
  • Informed consent should be obtained and reported where applicable.
  • Privacy, confidentiality, and data-protection requirements must be respected.
  • Authors must obtain appropriate consent for publication of identifiable information where applicable.
  • Animal research must comply with applicable welfare and ethical requirements.

Authors may be required to provide documentation of ethical approval, exemption, informed consent, institutional authorization, or related ethical compliance upon editorial request.

Data, Transparency & Reproducibility

Authors should report methods, data sources, analytical procedures, and research decisions with sufficient transparency to permit scholarly evaluation and, where reasonably possible, replication or reproducibility.

Authors may be requested to provide underlying data, code, instruments, documentation, or other research materials when necessary to evaluate manuscript integrity.

Where data cannot be shared because of privacy, confidentiality, legal, contractual, ethical, or proprietary restrictions, authors should explain the relevant limitations.

Peer Review Ethics

ABIM applies a double-anonymous peer-review process. Manuscripts progressing to external peer review are normally assessed by at least two independent reviewers.

  • Reviewers must maintain manuscript confidentiality.
  • Reviews must be objective, constructive, evidence-based, and respectful.
  • Reviewers must disclose relevant conflicts of interest.
  • Privileged information obtained through review must not be used for personal advantage.
  • Reviewers should complete assessments within the agreed period or notify the editor promptly.
  • Reviewer recommendations are advisory; final editorial decisions remain with authorized academic editors.
Editorial Ethics & Independence

Editors evaluate manuscripts according to scholarly merit, originality, methodological rigor, relevance to ABIM's Aims & Scope, research integrity, peer-review evidence, and compliance with journal policies.

Editorial decisions must not be influenced by authors' nationality, institutional affiliation, gender, religion, ethnicity, political beliefs, commercial relationships, or other characteristics unrelated to scholarly evaluation.

Editorial Independence: The publisher, advertising relationships, Article Processing Charges, institutional collaborations, sponsorships, and other financial considerations do not determine manuscript acceptance or rejection. Where applicable, APC payment is requested only after final academic acceptance.
Generative AI Policy
Authors

Authors may use Generative AI or AI-assisted technologies for appropriate support in manuscript preparation, such as improving language or readability, provided that human oversight is maintained and authors carefully review, verify, and take full responsibility for the final content.

AI tools cannot be listed as authors or co-authors because they cannot assume responsibility for the integrity, accuracy, originality, or accountability required of authors.

Where relevant, authors must disclose material use of Generative AI or AI-assisted technologies in accordance with ABIM manuscript requirements.

Reviewers & Editors

Reviewers and editors must protect manuscript confidentiality. Submitted manuscripts, unpublished data, supplementary materials, review reports, and confidential correspondence must not be uploaded to publicly accessible Generative AI systems or external tools where confidentiality, data security, intellectual property protection, or retention conditions cannot be assured.

Reviewers and editors remain personally responsible for professional judgment and editorial or review conclusions.

AI-Generated & AI-Assisted Visual Materials

AI-assisted diagrams or explanatory illustrations may be considered when their use is transparent, appropriate, lawful, and accurately represents the underlying information.

Authors remain responsible for verifying the accuracy, originality, copyright status, attribution, and integrity of all visual materials. AI-generated images must not be presented as genuine empirical, observational, experimental, or documentary evidence when they are not.

Corrections

Errors identified after publication are evaluated according to their nature and effect on the published record.

Where correction is appropriate, ABIM may publish a correction, corrigendum, erratum, or equivalent notice linked to the original article. The notice should identify the affected publication and describe the correction.

Retractions & Expressions of Concern

Retraction may be considered when published findings are unreliable because of fabrication, falsification, serious error, plagiarism, redundant publication, unethical research, serious authorship problems, manipulated peer review, or other circumstances that materially undermine publication integrity.

Retraction notices should identify the retracted article, explain the reason where appropriate, remain publicly accessible, and preserve the scholarly record.

Where concerns are serious but an investigation remains incomplete or inconclusive, the journal may issue an expression of concern when appropriate.

Manuscript Withdrawal

Authors requesting withdrawal of a manuscript before publication should contact the Editorial Office and clearly explain the reason for withdrawal.

ABIM does not impose a separate withdrawal fee. A withdrawal request does not prevent the journal from investigating suspected duplicate submission, misconduct, authorship disputes, or other integrity concerns identified during editorial processing.

Complaints & Appeals

Authors, reviewers, readers, and other stakeholders may submit complaints concerning editorial procedures, reviewer conduct, confidentiality, conflicts of interest, publication ethics, administrative processes, corrections, or other journal-related matters.

Authors may appeal an editorial decision when they believe a significant procedural or scholarly error affected the decision. Appeals should provide a clear explanation and relevant supporting information rather than simply expressing disagreement with the outcome.

Ethics, Complaint & Appeal Contact
Primary Email: editor@advancesinresearch.id
Alternative Email: advancesresearch@gmail.com
Official WhatsApp: +62 821 9454 8786
Copyright

Authors retain copyright in articles published by ABIM and grant the journal the right of first publication.

Authors remain responsible for ensuring that submitted content does not infringe copyright or other intellectual property rights and for obtaining necessary permission to reproduce third-party material.

Licensing
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
ABIM publishes articles under the CC BY 4.0 License ↗ .

Under CC BY 4.0, users may copy, redistribute, remix, transform, and build upon published material for any purpose, including commercially, provided appropriate attribution is given, a link to the license is provided, and changes are indicated where applicable.

No additional legal or technological restrictions may be imposed that prevent others from exercising rights permitted by the license.

Open Access Statement

ABIM provides immediate open access to published content. Readers may access published articles without subscription or registration barriers.

Open access supports wider dissemination, visibility, accessibility, reuse, and exchange of scholarly knowledge while preserving appropriate attribution to authors and the journal as the original place of publication.

Advertising Policy

ABIM may permit limited and selectively reviewed advertising or promotional content where appropriate. Advertising activities remain separate from academic editorial functions.

Advertising relationships do not influence editorial content, reviewer selection, peer-review decisions, manuscript acceptance, rejection, publication timing, or editorial priorities.

The presence of advertising does not constitute endorsement by ABIM or its publisher of any advertised institution, conference, organization, service, or product.

Direct Marketing

Any journal-related solicitation, call for papers, invitation, or promotional communication issued by ABIM should be accurate, professional, transparent, and not misleading. The journal does not promise guaranteed acceptance, guaranteed publication, favorable peer review, or indexing in exchange for submission or payment.

Post-Publication Discussion

ABIM supports responsible scholarly discussion concerning published work. Readers may contact the Editorial Office regarding substantive concerns, potential errors, requests for clarification, or publication-integrity matters. Appropriate editorial actions may include communication with authors, publication of corrections or responses, or further investigation.

Publisher Responsibility

ABIM is published by Yayasan Pendidikan Bukhari Dwi Muslim. The publisher supports journal administration, infrastructure, dissemination, technical operations, and publication continuity while respecting the independence of scholarly editorial decisions.

Commercial revenue, institutional collaboration, sponsorship, Article Processing Charges, or other financial relationships must not interfere with independent academic editorial evaluation.

Policy Application

ABIM may take appropriate editorial action when journal policies, research-integrity requirements, ethical standards, or publication agreements are violated. Actions are determined according to the seriousness of the matter, available evidence, stage of publication, and the need to protect the integrity of the scholarly record.

Where appropriate, ABIM may consult relevant COPE guidance, external experts, institutions, publishers, or other responsible organizations when addressing complex publication-ethics matters.

Related Journal Information
Publication Integrity Contact
Primary Email: editor@advancesinresearch.id
Alternative Email: advancesresearch@gmail.com
Official WhatsApp: +62 821 9454 8786

```